Made fresh every morning Sussex County favorite since 1998

Fresh, handmade fudge —
gift-ready and shipped with care.

Small-batch fudge stirred by hand every morning on Route 23, in the heart of Sussex County. Pick your favorites, build a gift box, and we'll ship it fresh nationwide — or have it waiting for local pickup.

Shop Best Sellers Build a Gift Box
4.9
Rated by 600+ happy fudge lovers · Google & in-store
Gift boxesfrom $15
Ships freshnationwide
The easiest gift you'll ever give

Gift boxes for every occasion

Hand-packed assortments built around our best sellers. Pick a size, add a note, and we handle the rest.

Birthdays Holidays Teacher gifts Thank-yous Housewarmings
Little Treat

The Sampler Box

$15 · 4 pieces

A perfect "thinking of you" gift — four half-slices of our most-loved flavors.

  • 4 classic flavors
  • Handwritten gift note
  • Ships fresh in 2 days
Most Popular

The Classic Box

$20 · 6 pieces

Our best-selling gift. Six generous slices spanning chocolate, caramel, and nutty favorites.

  • 6 curated flavors
  • Ribbon-tied keepsake box
  • Great for hostess & thank-yous
Premium

The Grand Box

$30 · 9 pieces

The showstopper. Nine full slices, including seasonal and specialty flavors — made to impress.

  • 9 flavors incl. specialty
  • Premium gift presentation
  • Corporate gifting available
Fan favorites

Best-selling fudge

Every slice is cut from a batch made this week — never sitting on a shelf.

View all fudge
Why Sussex County keeps coming back

Fresh you can taste. Service you can trust.

Voted Sussex County's Favorite Fudge

Local pickup on Route 23

Just minutes from Newton, Sparta and Vernon. Order online and grab it same-week — no line, no waiting.

Gift-ready in one click

Add a handwritten note at checkout and we'll ship a beautifully packed box straight to their door.

Made fresh, never mass-produced

Small batches, real butter and cream, stirred by hand. If it's not fresh, we don't sell it.

M
Maria D.Sparta, NJ · Verified buyer

"Sent the Classic Box to my mom three states away and it arrived perfectly fresh. She said it tasted better than anything local. Now it's our holiday tradition."

J
James R.Newton, NJ · Local regular

"Been stopping in on Route 23 for years. The chocolate walnut is unreal, and pickup ordering online now saves me every single time."

4.9 / 5 from 600+ Google reviews

Word of mouth, since 1998

Loved across Sussex County

From holiday gifts to farmers-market regulars — here's what neighbors are saying.

"I bring a Grand Box to every family Thanksgiving in Sparta and it's gone before dessert. Nobody makes fudge like Sue."

Holiday gift
L
Linda M.Sparta, NJ

"Grabbed teacher gifts here at the end of the school year — the handwritten notes made it. My kids' teachers still mention it."

Teacher gift
D
Dana K.Newton, NJ

"Found Sue's booth at a local craft fair years ago and now I stop by the Route 23 shop every trip up to Vernon. The sea salt caramel is dangerous."

Local event
R
Rob P.Vernon, NJ

"Ordered a birthday box shipped to my daughter at college. Arrived fresh and beautifully packed. This is our go-to gift now."

Birthday · Shipped
S
Susan F.Franklin, NJ
Sue making a fresh batch of handcrafted fudge in her Sussex County shop
Our story

Hi, I'm Sue.

What started as a copper pot in my kitchen turned into a little shop on Route 23 that folks from Newton, Sparta, Vernon and all over Sussex County have loved for over 25 years. I still use the same recipes my grandmother taught me — real cream, real butter, and no shortcuts.

Everything is made by hand in small batches — from our fudge to chocolate-covered pretzels, caramel apples, personalized cookies, and seasonal specialty gifts. From small-batch fudge to chocolate-covered treats, cookies, seasonal gifts, and custom sweets, Sue's Fudge offers something special for every occasion.

— Sue

25+Years on Route 23
30+Handmade flavors
600+5-star reviews
Read our full story

Send a little sweetness today

Build a gift box in under a minute — ships fresh nationwide or ready for pickup this week.

Build Your Gift Box